The Burden of the Beast

Countering Conspiracies and Misinformation within Indigenous Communities in Australia

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.2862

How to Cite

Fredericks, B., Bradfield, A., McAvoy, S., Ward, J., Spierings, S., Combo, T., & Toth-Peter, A. (2022). The Burden of the Beast: Countering Conspiracies and Misinformation within Indigenous Communities in Australia . M/C Journal, 25(1). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.2862 (Original work published March 16, 2022)
Vol. 25 No. 1 (2022): conspiracy
Published 2022-03-16 — Updated on 2022-03-17
Feature

Introduction

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, and its fluctuating waves of infections and the emergence of new variants, Indigenous populations in Australia and worldwide have remained at high risk. Indigenous populations are all too familiar with the deadly consequences of introduced disease. Outbreaks such as the H1N1 influenza epidemic in 2009 disproportionately impacted Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples (Komesaroff et al.; Eades et al.), while past epidemics introduced by colonisers have decimated, and in some cases eradicated entire language groups (Fredericks, Holcombe, and Bradfield).

As COVID-19 spreads, and highly contagious variants such as Omicron emerge, preventative measures and vaccinations have never been so important. Vaccination rates in some Indigenous communities, however, remain stubbornly low, with hesitancy coinciding with the spread of misinformation and amplification of conspiracy theories. In some cases, conspiracies have infiltrated Indigenous communities, playing on anxieties derived in part from the impact of colonisation, as well as past and present trauma. The scale of misinformation relating to COVID-19, particularly online, has become a worldwide problem with the World Health Organization terming it an “infodemic” (World Health Organization) and others a “misinfodemic” (Pickles et al.).

In this article, we discuss how conspiracies have impacted vaccination rates in some Indigenous communities in Australia. We acknowledge that vaccine hesitancy is not universal amongst all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and that differing responses to public health messaging are informed by diverse socio-historic factors. The most effective strategies towards curbing the spread of misinformation, and hopefully disease, however, arise from community-led and driven initiatives that are informed by evidence-based messaging that empowers Indigenous agency and choice.

Methodology

Our article draws on a study conducted at the University of Queensland (UQ) which documented and mapped some of the risk and protective measures that influence responses to COVID-19 in urban Brisbane (Fredericks et al. ‘Innovative Research’ and ‘Understanding Health’). Over the course of three workshops, held throughout 2021, stakeholder participants from the Indigenous health sector (both Indigenous and non-Indigenous) – including representation from Aboriginal Controlled Community Health Organisations – shared anecdotal and empirical evidence that amongst other findings demonstrated the impact of circulating misinformation.

In this article, we triangulate some of the findings from these workshops with accompanying literature gathered from journal articles, news and social media, and other online sources that have documented accounts relating to conspiracies in Indigenous Australian communities. We argue that successful communications relating to COVID-19 in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities necessitates that health messaging centralise Indigenous voices and expertise.

Conspiracies and Colonialism

Settler colonialism is relevant to our discussion concerning the prevalence of conspiracy theories in some Indigenous communities in Australia, as their pervasive nature has shaped a culture of mistrust and scepticism towards dominant hegemonic structures. Colonisation was, and still is, an ongoing process that impacts on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in different regions, in different ways (Wolfe). The prolonged invasion and spread of colonisers throughout the continent resulted in varied, but equally violent, frontier encounters that were informed by the authoritarian structures, policies, and attitudes of the time.

Whilst “Indigenous Affairs” – and the policies relating to them – have changed over Australia’s history, responses were/are united through an ethos of “possession” that dehumanises Indigenous peoples and cultures through the proclamation of white sovereignty (Moreton-Robinson). This is demonstrated through state sanctioned practices, such as the removal and institutionalisation of Aboriginal children, now known as the Stolen Generations, or the disproportionate rates of policing and incarceration that have contributed to Indigenous deaths in custody.

Missionaries are the by-products of colonisation, and as Noel Pearson has written have complex and conflicting places in some Indigenous peoples‘ lives; being both locations of immense traumas as well as sanctuaries separated from the violence that took place beyond their confines. While missionaries have since transitioned into state-controlled settlements, and then communities and outstations, Christianity and the Christian Church continues to be meaningful for many Indigenous peoples who came from or are kin to those who live in areas formerly controlled and run by religious institutions. As we discuss in the next section, religious dogma and rhetoric has been manipulated and used to target and spread conspiracies about COVID-19 in some Indigenous communities.

To better understand conspiracies, however, we argue that we must move beyond the impulse to dismiss them as mere absurdities, but rather unpack the socio-political contexts in which they are constructed, framed, and interpreted (Jane and Fleming). Prasad (13) argues that conspiracies “seem to embody displacement and condensation of not only the past experiences of an individual but also the history of the social group to which s/he/they belong”. Pierre suggests that conspiracies are best understood not through the narratives they propagate, but rather through those they reject. Beliefs in conspiracies therefore can provide a sense membership and belonging among those who rightly or wrongly feel disenfranchised (Douglas et al.).

While a sense of disenfranchisement can influence a person’s inclination towards a conspiracy, conspiracists do not always exist on the fringes of society, nor do their theories reflect the nonsensical ramblings of vocal minorities who counter the so-called “rational” views of the mainstream.  Within colonial spaces, topics relating to invasion, possession, and dispossession have resulted in conspiratorial silences that veil the ongoing impact of imperialism on Indigenous peoples in Australia and throughout the world (Moreton-Robinson).

The failure of settler-nations to confront and address the ongoing violence of colonisation have been described by some as a “conspiracy of silence” (Bottoms and Evans), or a form of hegemonic “amnesia” (Langton). These national silences fuel some Indigenous people’s mistrust in the governing authorities who continuously fail to recognise Indigenous sovereignty. Public health mandates, therefore – when delivered by governments blind to Indigenous cultural protocols – become less about health protection or inoculation per se, but rather serve as touchpoints of conflict that render the unresolved nature of colonisation, visible. In other words, it reflects the question over who has the right and authority to insert their power over Indigenous bodies?

Everyday lived experiences with racism, stereotype, intergenerational harm, and maltreatment within the health system can correlate with a person’s receptivity to conspiracy theories (Smith et al.). Indigenous people, and other persons of colour, have long been subjected to maltreatment and/or medical experimentation that has manifested in intergenerational harm and mistrust (Anderson; Pierre). In The Cultivation of Whiteness, Anderson presents a body of work that centralises whiteness within the medical field, outlining how in the twentieth century medicine operated (and still operates) as a “discourse of settlement” through the definition and control of Black bodies (Fredericks). Anderson writes, “the medical construction of white Australia provides another lens through which we may view two hundred years of European settlement” (5). Explanations for vaccine hesitancy amongst Indigenous people – even if they are rooted in conspiracy – cannot be removed from this context of colonial disempowerment.

The anti-vax movement – like other discourses and praxes in the public and private sector (Bargallie) – often reflects a racialised colonial discourse. Day and Carlson observe how TikTok influencers and white supremacists in the USA have used language such as “pureblood” in reference to their so-called “supremacy” of having blood untainted by the vaccine (Owen). While messaging such as this often originates abroad, far right groups have strategically manipulated information online so that it may infiltrate Indigenous communities in Australia, preying on pre-existing anxieties. Northern Territory Chief Minister Michael Gunner has directly attributed many of the rumours circulating in Central Australia to foreign intervention (Allam), with similar claims being made in Western Australia and elsewhere (Orr).

The Spread of Conspiracy in Indigenous Communities

Since the outbreak of COVID-19, numerous conspiracies have emerged attempting to explain the virus through narratives that suggest it is part of an organised initiative to dismantle world order or control global populations. One such conspiracy posits that the virus and the major organisations, individuals, and authorities associated with its prevention are carrying out the work of the devil or the “Beast” (Bohlinge; Letšosa). The spread of misinformation associating vaccines to the “mark of the Beast” has gained momentum in some Aboriginal communities in Australia (Roussos) – particularly in locations that have long histories with Christian missionaries.

In some instances, as discussed in the case studies below, individuals have deliberately targeted Indigenous communities and played on anxieties for personal and ideological gain. This is concerning given the already low vaccination rate in communities such as Ali Curung in the Barkley Region, Northern Territory (Roussos), and regions such as the Kimberly and Pilbara where just 10% of the Aboriginal population is vaccinated (Parke and Lynch).

Between March and June 2021, emails were sent to the Pastor of Ninga Mia in Western Australia which likened vaccines to the “mark of the Beast” and suggested that it contained an enzyme named after the devil (Richards et al.). These were reportedly sent by Kris Schlyder, the head of the Australian Indigenous Prayer Network in Queensland, who claimed he forwarded the emails after receiving them from a pastor in the United States. Similar examples have occurred in other communities such as Santa Teresa (Roussos).

Ninga Mia’s pastor, Geoffrey Stokes, and his wife Dr. Jeffries-Stokes have stated that rumours and awareness of the (false) claims have become so pervasive in their community that vaccine advocacy is met with condemnation by some members of the community who believe the pair have turned their backs on their faith. This suggests that the mere spread of rumour can sow the seed of doubt and exacerbate pre-existing hesitancies. Despite platforms such as Twitter banning the hashtags #MarkOfTheBeastIsTheCovid19Vaccine and #VaccineIsTheMarkOfTheBeast, in attempts to stop the spread of religious misinformation (Dwoskin 2021), they continue to circulate and hinder assurances.

In some cases, Indigenous and non-Indigenous service providers have contributed and accelerated the spread of misinformation (Bryne et al.). Community representatives from the Larrakia Nation for example were forced to issue a declaration refuting the views of the Larrakia Sovereign Tribal Council (see Fig. 1) who falsely proclaimed that morgues were in danger of being overrun due to the increasing deaths associated with vaccinations on Groote Eylandt (Bryne et al.). This demonstrates the challenge of how to effectively communicate and expose health messaging from sources that are COVID-19 literate, trusted, and able to counter the spread of misinformation.   

Larrakia Nation

Fig. 1: Larrakia Nation Facebook post (2021)

Involvement of the Australian Defence Force, who assisted in moving residents in remote locations living in overcrowded houses containing upwards of 30 people, has falsely been likened to the Stolen Generations by some (Allam). Historic events and ongoing processes of removing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children; unsolicited involvement of Australia’s Defence Forces during the “National Emergency” of 2007; and other exploits of government intervention in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people’s lives have been manipulated in ways that empowers the divisive agenda of extremist groups.

False associations such as these not only impacts vaccine hesitancy but resurface trauma by trivialising past lived experiences and falsifying narratives for a racialised agenda. Katherine community health worker Luke Ellis, whose mother is a member of the Stolen Generations, has stated that any “comparison to stolen generation is spitting on what those poor souls went through in those days” (Allam).

There have also been reports of “Blackfishing” in some communities, a process that seeks to manipulate and capitalise on Black culture for economic and/or political gain (Stevens). Blackfishing has targeted remote Indigenous people by falsely associating COVID-19 vaccinations with a “new genocide”. Lorraine Anderson, member of the Kimberley Aboriginal Medical Service, has commented that “unfortunately, because of historical injustice around how the various governments have treated Indigenous people, there is an underlying mistrust of government information. So it’s a minefield for us to work our way around that” (Aboriginal Medical Services Alliance Northern Territory). This poses the question of how to successfully navigate such “minefields” and deliver verified information from trusted sources.

Taming the Beast of Misinformation

Indigenous peoples have long been aware of the risks of pandemics (Fredericks, Holcombe, and Bradfield) and were quick to implement the measures necessary to ensure the safety of their communities (Fredericks and Bradfield “Indigenous Australians and COVID-19” and “We Don’t Want”). In some locations, testing rates amongst Aboriginal peoples exceeded those of non-Indigenous populations (Wilson-Matenga et al.). Some communities were mobilising and working on messaging before the outbreak was officially declared a pandemic in March 2020 (Stefanoff). Furthermore, Indigenous communities in Victoria embraced vaccination at a rate that exceeded that of non-Indigenous Australians, the success being attributed to transparency, effective communication, and the trust placed in the Victorian Aboriginal Health Services (Syron).

In September 2021, the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) organised a meeting with 14 Aboriginal church leaders to discuss the spread of misinformation (Jenkins). Led by NACCHO CEO Pat Turner and Minister for Indigenous Australians Ken Wyatt, the meeting provided an opportunity to discuss strategies to counter misinformation in ways that are culturally appropriate and respectful of communities’ beliefs (Wyatt). Minister Wyatt acknowledged that “uniting faith-based and medical messaging will be key to stamping out the dangerous rhetoric and boost vaccine uptake in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities” (Coughlan). National Cabinet also met in January 2022, recognising that “everyone was facing difficulties driving Indigenous vaccination rates given misinformation in parts of those [remote] communities" (Stayner).

Vicki O’Donnell, the CEO of Kimberley Aboriginal Medical Services, has observed that over her 25-year career, this is the first instance of religious groups being active around the anti-vaccination space. Chief Executive of the Mallee District Aboriginal Services in Victoria Jacki Turfrey has called for more targeted responses to address and dispel each of the myths circulating, indicating that this burden often falls on the shoulders of frontline workers (Bain).

Community health organisations and frontline workers have placed considerable time and energy in countering misinformation. In Western Australia, Yamatji Noongar community leader Sharon Wood-Kenney has talked through communities’ concerns in a manner that acknowledges the impact of past government policies such as the Stolen Generations and the understandable mistrust that has come from it, while reiterating the importance and relative low risk of vaccination (Bain).

Principle 8 of the Roadmap to Recovery – an independent report devised by a taskforce made up of eight leading Australian universities – refers to the need to counter misinformation through increasing transparency, and in doing so, preventing “information gaps” being filled by conspiracy theories. Frontline Indigenous workers and community leaders who are knowledgeable in health practice, trusted members of their community, and are astute to the diversity of cultural protocols play a vital role in alleviating these gaps (Danchin et al.). Hyland-Wood, Gardner, Leask, and Ecker argue that while trust must be a two-way process between governments and communities, it should always be communicated by credible and trusted sources who have nuanced knowledge specific to particular socio-cultural contexts.

Social media networks have provided many Indigenous people with access to information via trusted sources that counter and refute misinformation and/or anxieties associated with dominant heath advice and messaging (Carlson et al.; Fredericks and Bradfield “‘Seeking to Be Heard”; Fredericks et al.). Indigenous communities are taking charge in addressing vaccine hesitancy and the conspiracies often attached to them. COVID-19 has largely highlighted the strengths of Indigenous peoples’ capacity to mitigate risk by implementing the measures necessary for their specific local needs (Wilson-Matenga et al.).

As social media is a popular outlet of communication for many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, in both remote and urban settings (Carlson and Frazer), its ability to disseminate targeted information makes it particularly effective in educating and reassuring communities of the necessity, and relative low risk, of vaccination. Online trends such as posting photos and videos of Indigenous people getting vaccinated, situates the messaging within a local and relational setting.   

Clear, transparent, and culturally appropriate language and imagery is vital to delivering health messaging. The Ampilatwatja community, for example, translated health messaging into culturally appropriate terms making it not only linguistically comprehensive but placing it within a familiar lived context. Social distancing was translated to ament angkem meaning “separate talking” while arteny, or “sitting down”, was used to explain lockdowns (Stefanoff). In Arnhem Land, the Yolngu word goŋwukundi, meaning a law determining what you can do and where you can go was used to explain “social distancing”. The concept of a virus which is present but invisible was explained via the phrase buwayak warrakan mala describing animals and birds who remain invisible. The importance of framing vaccination as a continuation of ongoing practices of keeping kin and Country healthy – demonstrated through memes such as “My mob said it was okay” (see Fig. 2) – cannot be understated.

Fig. 2: uprisingofthepeople (2021)

Responses to COVID-19 and the spread of misinformation must be forward-thinking, long-term, and holistic. Interventions and education should be responsive to varying levels of health literacy, as this, paired with disparate socio-economic status and inherent mistrust of mainstream authorities (Lewandowsky and Cook) have correlations to vaccination rates and one’s potential to turn to conspiracies (McCaffery et al.; Pickles et al.). This is exacerbated in “high-impact scenarios” where risk and high probability of a real or perceived threat increases anxieties and creates a “cognitive bias” that informs how such scenarios are understood and responded to (Kovic and Fuchslin).

Vaccine hesitancy is best understood and addressed in relation to the interlocking factors that drive anxieties and limit vaccine uptake (Goorie; Fredericks et al.). Inoculation theory or pre-bunking, where communities are equipped with the health literacy needed to evaluate (mis)information before it takes hold (Cook et al.; Jolley and Douglas), can potentially address vaccine hesitancy by empowering communities with knowledge. Many Indigenous communities and organisations are already taking pre-bunking approaches. Organisations such Why Warriors, for example, have remained dedicated to providing accessible information that empowers Aboriginal communities to make informed decisions.

Why Warriors, based in Yolngu Country in the Northern Territory has procured a range of resources including podcasts, radio outputs, videos, and in-person sessions held in Yolngu Matha language (Why Warriors). The organisation has observed that there is a great desire for in-depth scientific knowledge pertaining to the virus within Aboriginal communities; however, this is not always accessible due to language and cross-cultural barriers. The resources Why Warriors produce are based on an informed cross-cultural methodology that seeks to understand and respond to communities’ concerns and the drivers behind vaccine hesitancy. The information provided is based on medical and Indigenous knowledge, and is a direct response to the questions, information gaps, and contradictions prevalent in community.

Why Warriors is just one example of culturally appropriate approaches to pre-bunking that “is not just about getting vaccinated but having a well-rounded understanding of the whole subject in order to deal with new developments and health issues in the future” (Trudgen et al. 3). The organisation with community organisations and frontline workers has successfully boosted vaccination rates, with estimates indicating that due to their community engagement on Elcho Island, and a presence during the Galiwin'ku Festival, vaccination rates increased from 30 inoculations to 80 per day (Trudgen et al.).

Conclusion

The word “conspire” derives from Latin, meaning to “breathe together” (Jane and Fleming). Co-designed Indigenous-led partnerships between governments (policymakers) and Indigenous communities are critical in ensuring that community leaders, organisations, and frontline workers are adequately resourced and financed so that health literacy can be improved as a protective strategy. For many Indigenous peoples, mistrust in government-led health interventions such as the COVID-19 vaccination rollout is a by-product of settler-colonialism informed by a history of state-sanctioned violence, invasion (of Country and body), and punitive measures of control. For some Indigenous people, conspiracies may provide an outlet through which to voice outrage at white systems of governance that are inherently violent and oppressive.

While mistrust does not necessarily equate to a proclivity towards conspiracy theories, greater accessibility to misinformation online has provided fertile ground for an infodemic of manipulated and distorted facts, circulated for personal and/or ideological gain (Alam and Chu). The stakeholders who contributed to UQ’s study on COVID-19 responses in urban Indigenous communities expressed their grave concerns over the impact of spreading misinformation. Such mistruths have the potential of further infiltrating Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, exacerbating pre-existing anxieties, breaking down trust and relationships, and having a ripple effect that places an already vulnerable population at further risk of succumbing to COVID-19.

Throughout this article we have discussed the spread of misinformation primarily through conspiracy theories with religious connotations and that liken vaccination to the biblical reference of the “mark of the Beast”. It is important to note, however, that such claims represent an extremist view and have been refuted by religious leaders such as Aboriginal pastor Geoffrey Stoke and, at the highest level, Pope Francis.

Within communities where distrust of government is ripe, and fears and lived experiences of disposition ongoing, rumours and misinformation can quickly spread via social networks. Whilst more needs to be done to regulate the spread of misinformation on social and online media, responses to information gaps and trust in health directives must be informed by Indigenous peoples, including the messaging. The stakeholders who took part in UQ’s study identified several touchpoints where interventions could help counter the spread of misinformation and the mistruths that compromise preventative behaviours. Some of these include:

  • Substantiating medical messaging with the voices of Elders, leaders, and trusted community members.
  • Increasing the Indigenous workforce to continue to provide trusted services, while also offsetting burnout.
  • Provide greater resourcing and financing to existing services who are carrying the burden of countering misinformation, often from sources external to the community.
  • Recognise that services and organisations may help engage Indigenous communities and provide access to verified information.
  • Address the systemic and underlying social and health “gaps” that inform Indigenous peoples’ vulnerabilities and contribute to a culture of mistrust in non-Indigenous authorities.
  • Create and/or enforce the legal and political mechanisms that will ensure Indigenous representation across all levels of governments and provide a voice that may oversee the implementation of co-designed strategies.

The burden carried as a result of spreading conspiracy theories can be alleviated by empowering Indigenous communities via decision-making and governance processes, creating structural and systemic change, closing pre-existing health gaps, improving health literacy, and increasing Indigenous representation in the workforce and across all levels of government, along with resourcing. Only when health systems “breathe together” with Indigenous peoples may the burden of the so-called Beast be overcome, and Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples can collectively conspire towards equitable health outcomes.  

References

Aboriginal Medical Services Alliance Northern Territory. "Blackfishing Used to Spread Anti-Vax Message: From the Weekend Australian." Facebook 29 Jan. 2022. 30 Jan. 2022 <https://m.facebook.com/101029641248834/posts/651673502851109/>.

Alam, Noore, and Cordia Chu. “Covid-19 Pandemic: Tackling ‘Infodemics’ through an Integrated One Health–Social Science Approach”. Proceedings of The Royal Society of Queensland 128 (2020).

Allam, Lorena. "‘Tinfoil Hat Wearing Tossers’: Nt Chief Minister and Aboriginal Elders Hit Back at Covid ‘False Information’." The Guardian, 25 Nov. 2021. 3 Dec. 2021 <https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/nov/25/tinfoil-hat-wearing-tossers-nt-chief-minister-and-aboriginal-elders-hit-back-at-covid-false-information>.

Anderson, Warwick. The Cultivation of Whiteness: Science, Health, and Racial Destiny in Australia. Duke University Press, 2006.

Andrews, Robert. "Using Conspiracy Theories to Teach Source Analysis." Teaching History 48.4 (2014): 64-65.  <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.931043490998683>.

Bain, Lucy. "‘Myths’ Harmed Indigenous Vaccine Rate, Says Mdas." Sunraysia Daily, 6 Sep. 2021.  17 Sep. 2021 <https://www.sunraysiadaily.com.au/coronavirus-covid-19/5090523/myths-harmed-indigenous-vaccine-rate-says-mdas>.

Bargallie, Debbie. Unmasking the Racial Contract: Indigenous Voices on Racism in the Australian Public Service. Aboriginal Studies Press, 2020.

Barkun, Michael. A Culture of Conspiracy. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2013.

Bohlinger, Tavis. "The Covid Vaccine Has 666 Written All over It… and Why That Doesn’t Matter According to Revelation." theLAB 18 May 2020. 7 Sep. 2021 >https://academic.logos.com/the-covid-vaccine-has-666-written-all-over-it-and-why-that-doesnt-matter-according-to-revelation/>.

Bottoms, Timothy, and Raymond Evans. “European Invasion of the Future Central Queensland.” In Conspiracy of Silence: Queensland's Frontier Killing-Times. Ed. T. Bottoms. Crows Nest, NSW: Allen & Unwin, 2013. 46–59.

Bruns, Axel, Stephen Harrington, and Edward Hurcombe. "'Corona? 5G? Or Both?’: The Dynamics of COVID-19/5G Conspiracy Theories on Facebook." Media International Australia 177 (2020): 12-29.  <https://doi.org/10.1177/1329878X20946113>.

Butts, Amber. "Even When Black Conspiracy Theories Are Misguided, They Are Not Nonsensical." Racebaitr 1 Oct. 2019. 18 Sep. 2021 <https://racebaitr.com/2019/10/01/even-when-black-conspiracy-theories-are-misguided-they-are-not-nonsensical/>.

Byrne, Conor, Jack Hislop, and Adam Steer. "Doctor Warns Anti-Vax Rumours, 'All Sorts of Really Weird, Irrational Logic', Rife in Remote Communities." ABC News 30 Sep. 2021. 1 Oct. 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-09-30/gp-warns-anti-vax-rumours-rife-in-remote-communities/100498322>.

Carlson, Bronwyn, and Ryan Frazer. "Social Media Mob: Being Indigenous Online." Sydney: Macquarie University, 2018. 

Carlson, Bronwyn, Ryan Frazer, and Terri Farrelly. “‘That Makes All the Difference’: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health-Seeking on Social Media.” Health Promotion Journal of Australia 32.3 (2021): 523-531 <https://doi.org/10.1002/hpja.366>.

Coade, Melissa. “Minister Tries to Map Path to Boost Vaccine Rates among Indigenous Australians.” The Mandarin 7 Sep. 2021. 2 Oct. 2021 <https://www.themandarin.com.au/168042-minister-tries-to-map-path-to-boost-vaccine-rates-among-indigenous-australians/>.

Compton, Josh, Sander van der Linden, John Cook, and Melisa Basol. "Inoculation Theory in the Post‐Truth Era: Extant Findings and New Frontiers for Contested Science, Misinformation, and Conspiracy Theories." Social and Personality Psychology Compass 15.6 (2021): e12602. <https://doi.org/10.1111/spc3.12602>.

Cook, John, Stephan Lewandowsky, and Ullrich KH Ecker. "Neutralizing Misinformation through Inoculation: Exposing Misleading Argumentation Techniques Reduces Their Influence." PloS one 12.5 (2017): e0175799. <https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.f17j3>.

Coughlan, Matt. “Indigenous Leaders in Talks over Jab Lies.” The Canberra Times 6 Sep. 2021. 10 Sep. 2021 <https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/7417592/indigenous-leaders-in-talks-over-jab-lies/>.

Cromb, Nat. “COVOD-19 and Custody – Calls for Release.” IndigenousX 25 Mar. 2020. 17 July 2021 <https://indigenousx.com.au/covid-19-and-custody-calls-for-release/>.

Danchin, Margie, Ruby Biezen, Jo-Anne Manski-Nankervis, Jessica Kaufman, and Julie Leask. "Preparing the Public for Covid-19 Vaccines: How Can General Practitioners Build Vaccine Confidence and Optimise Uptake for Themselves and Their Patients?" Australian Journal of General Practice 49.10 (2020): 625-29. <https://doi.org/10.31128/ajgp-08-20-5559>.

Day, Madi, and Bronwyn Carlson. "White Supremacist and Far Right Ideology Underpin Anti-Vax Movements." The Conversation 22 Nov. 2021. 25 Nov. 2021 <https://theconversation.com/white-supremacist-and-far-right-ideology-underpin-anti-vax-movements-172289>.

De Pinho, Helen. "Systems Tools for Complex Health Systems: A Guide to Creating Causal Loop Diagrams." New York: Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, 2015. 17-19. <https://www.who.int/alliance-hpsr/resources/publications/CLD_Course_Participant_Manual.pdf>.

Dikian, Jack. "Why Tin Foil Hats Are Useful: Are Conspiracy Theories Just Part of Our Evolutionary History?" The Australian Rationalist 119 (2020): 7. <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.697637095504718>.

Doherty, Linda. "Joining the Dots: How Wide-Ranging Forces Are Undermining Public Health Responses to the Pandemic." Croakey Health Media 22 Sep. 2021. 25 Sep. 2021 <https://www.croakey.org/joining-the-dots-how-wide-ranging-forces-are-undermining-public-health-responses-to-the-pandemic/>.  

Douglas, Karen M., Robbie M. Sutton, and Aleksandra Cichocka. "The Psychology of Conspiracy Theories." Current Directions in Psychological Science 26.6 (2017): 538-42. <https://doi.org/10.1177%2F0963721417718261>.

Dwoskin, Elizabeth. "On Social Media, Vaccine Misinformation Mixes with Extreme Faith." The Washington Post 16 Feb. 2021. 21 July 2021 <https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/02/16/covid-vaccine-misinformation-evangelical-mark-beast>.

Faasse, Kate, and Jill Newby. "Public Perceptions of Covid-19 in Australia: Perceived Risk, Knowledge, Health-Protective Behaviors, and Vaccine Intentions." Frontiers in Psychology 11 (2020): 551004. <https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.551004>.

Fegebank, John. "Shifting the Blame: How a Condemnation of the Far Right Became an Open Attack on the Left." Guardian (Sydney). 1950 (2021): 10. <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.714239072430113>.

First Draft. "Vaccine Misinformation Insights Report: July." First Draft News 5 Aug. 2021. 18 Aug. 2021 <https://firstdraftnews.org/long-form-article/vaccine-misinformation-insights-report-july/>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn. "'There Is Nothing That Identifies Me to That Place': Indigenous Women's Perceptions of Health Spaces and Places”. Critical Studies Review 15.2 (2009): 29-44. <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.699277759963008>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, and Abraham Bradfield. “Indigenous Australians and COVID-19: Highlighting Ongoing Food Security Issues.” International Journal of Home Economics 14.2 (2021): 53–65. <https://www.ifhe.org/fileadmin/user_upload/e_Journal/vol_14_1/P4_Fredericks-Bradfield.pdf>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, and Abraham Bradfield. “‘Seeking to Be Heard’: The Role of Social and Online Media in Advocating for the Uluru Statement from the Heart and Constitutional Reform in Australia.” Journal of Alternative & Community Media 6.1 (2021): 27-52.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, and Abraham Bradfield. "We Don’t Want to Go Back to ‘Normal’, When ‘Normal’ Wasn’t Good for Everyone." Axon: Creative Explorations 10.2 (2020). <https://axonjournal.com.au/issue-vol-10-no-2-dec-2020/we-don-t-want-go-back-normal-when-normal-wasn-t-good-everyone>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, Abraham Bradfield, Jenny Nguyen, and Samar Ansell. “Disrupting the Colonial Algorithm: Indigenous Australia and Social Media.” Media International Australia (2021): 1–21. <https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1329878X211038286>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, Sarah Holcombe, and Abraham Bradfield. "Reconciliation Week: A Time to Reflect on Strong Indigenous Leadership and Resilience in the Face of a Pandemic." The Conversation, 29 May 2020. 29 May 2020 <https://theconversation.com/reconciliation-week-a-time-to-reflect-on-strong-indigenous-leadership-and-resilience-in-the-face-of-a-pandemic-139311>.

Fredericks, Bronwyn, James Ward, Sue McAvoy, Troy Combo, Shae Spierings, Abraham Bradfield, and Agnes Toth-Peter. "Innovative Research Explores Responses to Covid-19 among Indigenous Communities in Brisbane." Croakey Health Media 8 Sep. 2021. 8 Sep. 2021 <https://www.croakey.org/innovative-research-explores-responses-to-covid-19-among-indigenous-communities-in-brisbane/>.

Frenkel, Sheera, Davey Alba, and Raymond Zhong. "Surge of Virus Misinformation Stumps Facebook and Twitter." The New York Times 8 Mar. 2020. 3 Nov. 2021 <https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/08/technology/coronavirus-misinformation-social-media.html>.

Goorie, Nayaka. “Why Vaccination Presents an Ethical Dilemma for Us, But Remains the Best Way to Keep Our Families Safe.” IndigenousX 12 Oct. 2021. 17 Oct. 2021 <https://indigenousx.com.au/why-vaccination-presents-an-ethical-dilemma-for-us-but-remains-the-best-way-to-keep-our-families-safe/>.

Graham, Timothy, Axel Bruns, Guangnan Zhu, and Rod Campbell. "Like a Virus: The Coordinated Spread of Coronavirus Disinformation." Canberra: The Australia Institute, 2020. <https://apo.org.au/node/305864>.

Group of Eight Australia. "Covid‐19: Roadmap to Recovery: A Report for the Nation." The Group of Eight Ltd, 2020. <https://go8.edu.au/research/roadmap-to-recovery>.

Guerin, Cécile, Jacob Davey, Mario Peucker, and Thomas J. Fisher. "The Interplay between Australia's Political Fringes on the Right and Left: Online Messaging on Facebook." CRIS, 2020. <https://www.isdglobal.org/isd-publications/interplay-australia-political-fringes/>.

Hil, Richard. "Here We Go Again: The Conspiracy Theory Freight Train." Social Alternatives 39.3 (2020): 38-39. <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.767846130739955>.

Hokowhitu, Brendan. "Monster: Post-Indigenous Studies." Critical Indigenous Studies: Engagements in First World Locations. Ed. Aileen Moreton-Robinson. Arizona: University of Arizona Press, 2016. 83-101.

Hyland-Wood, Bernadette, John Gardner, Julie Leask, and Ullrich K.H. Ecker. "Toward Effective Government Communication Strategies in the Era of Covid-19." Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 8.1 (2021): 1-11. <https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-020-00701-w>.

Jane, Emma A., and Chris Fleming. Modern Conspiracy: The Importance of Being Paranoid. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing USA, 2014.

Jenkins, Keira. “Indigenous Pastors Link Up to Strike Down COVID Misinformation.” NITV 6 Sep. 2021. 15 Sep. 2021 <https://www.sbs.com.au/nitv/article/2021/09/06/indigenous-pastors-link-strike-down-covid-misinformation>.

Jolley, Daniel, and Karen M. Douglas. "Prevention Is Better than Cure: Addressing Anti‐Vaccine Conspiracy Theories." Journal of Applied Social Psychology 47.8 (2017): 459-69. <https://psycnet.apa.org/doi/10.1111/jasp.12453>.

Klein, Colin, Peter Clutton, and Vince Polito. "Topic Modeling Reveals Distinct Interests within an Online Conspiracy Forum." Frontiers in Psychology 9.189 (2018). <https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.00189>.

Kovic, Marko, and Tobias Füchslin. "Probability and Conspiratorial Thinking." Applied Cognitive Psychology 32.3 (2018): 390-400. <https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.3408>.

Larrakia Nation. “Larrakia Please Be Aware…” Facebook 13 Sep. 2021. 17 Sep. 2021 <https://www.facebook.com/larrakianation/>.

Letšosa, Rantoa. "What Has the Beast’s Mark to Do with the Covid-19 Vaccination, and What Is the Role of the Church and Answering to the Christians?" HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies 77.4 (2021). <http://dx.doi.org/10.4102/hts.v77i4.6480>.

Lewandowsky, Stephan, and John Cook. The Conspiracy Theory Handbook. Center for Climate Change Communication, George Mason University, 2020. <http://sks.to/conspiracy>.   

Mangan, Sinead. “Covid Vax Conspiracies Spread Fear among Regional Indigenous Communities.” ABC Australia Wide 5 July 2021. 20 Aug. 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/radio/programs/australia-wide/australia-wide/13422642>.

McCaffery, Kirsten, Rachael Dodd, Erin Cvejic, Julie Ayre, Carys Batcup, Jennifer Isautier, Tessa Copp, Carissa Bonner, Kristen Pickles, Brooke Nickel, Tom Dakin, Samuel Cornell, and Michael Wolf. "Disparities in Covid-19 Related Knowledge, Attitudes, Beliefs and Behaviours by Health Literacy." medRxiv (2020). <https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.06.03.20121814>.

Monk, Paul. "Cognitive Snares: A Few Thoughts on Covid-19 Conspiracy Theories." The Australian Rationalist 117 (2020): 5-6. <https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.696276888602870>.

Moreton-Robinson, Aileen. The White Possessive Property, Power and Indigenous Sovereignty. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2015.

NACCHO. “Vaccine Conspiracies Target Vulnerable Communities.” NACCHO Aboriginal Health News 4 Sep. 2021. 19 Sep. 2021. <https://nacchocommunique.com/2021/09/04/naccho-aboriginal-health-news-mon-6-7-21/>.

Orr, Aleisha. "Covid-19 Conspiracy Theories Peddled to Aboriginal Communities by US-Based White Supremacists." National Indigenous Times 6 Dec. 2021. 6 Dec. 2021 <https://nit.com.au/covid-19-conspiracy-theories-peddled-to-aboriginal-communities-by-us-based-white-supremacists/>.

O'Sullivan, John. "Bill Gates Admits Covid Vaccine Changes DNA, Now Doctors Rebel!" Principia Scientific International 5 Dec. 2020. 18 Feb. 2021 <https://principia-scientific.com/bill-gates-admits-covid-vaccine-changes-dna-now-doctors-rebel>.

Parke, Erin, and Jacqueline Lynch. "'Vaccine Is Satan' Rumours amid Low Indigenous Covid-19 Jab Rates." ABC News 6 Sep. 2021. 9 Sep. 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-09-06/anti-vacc-church-speaks-out-against-misinformation/100430208>.

Pennycook, Gordon, Jonathon McPhetres, Yunhao Zhang, Jackson G. Lu, and David G. Rand. "Fighting Covid-19 Misinformation on Social Media: Experimental Evidence for a Scalable Accuracy-Nudge Intervention." Psychological Science 31.7 (2020): 770-80. <https://doi.org/10.1177%2F0956797620939054>.

Pickles, Kristen, Erin Cvejic, Brooke Nickel, Tessa Copp, Carissa Bonner, Julie Leask, Julie Ayre, Carys Batcup, Samuel Cornell, Thomas Dakin, Rachael Dodd, Jennifer Isautier, and Kirsten McCaffery. "Covid-19: Beliefs in Misinformation in the Australian Community." Medrxiv (2020). <https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.08.04.20168583>.

Pierre, Joseph M. "Mistrust and Misinformation: A Two-Component, Socio-Epistemic Model of Belief in Conspiracy Theories." Journal of Social and Political Psychology 8.2 (2020): 617-41. <https://dx.doi.org/10.5964/jspp.v8i2.1362>.

Prasad, Amit. "Anti-Science Misinformation and Conspiracies: Covid–19, Post-Truth, and Science & Technology Studies (STS)." Science, Technology and Society Apr. 2021. <https://doi.org/10.1177%2F09717218211003413>.

Rallah-Baker, Kris. “We Live in Dangerous Times, Not Unprecedented Times.” IndigenousX 26 Mar. 2020. 10 July 2021 <https://indigenousx.com.au/we-live-in-dangerous-times-not-unprecedented-times/>.

Rendall, Jessica. "Coronavirus Fears Prompts Queensland Boarding School to Quarantine Students Returning from China." ABC News 28 Jan. 2020. 15 July 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-01-28/coronavirus-queensland-boarding-school-quarantines-students/11903660>.

Richards, Abby, Eliza Borrello, and Tom Edwards. "Why Some Aboriginal People Are Too Scared to Get Vaccinated." ABC News 4 July 2021. 7 Sep. 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-07-04/indigenous-covid-vaccine-pastor/100263770>.

Roose, Josh. "‘It’s Almost Like Grooming’: How Anti-Vaxxers, Conspiracy Theorists, and the Far-Right Came Together over Covid." The Conversation 21 Sep. 2021. 25 Sep. 2021 <https://theconversation.com/its-almost-like-grooming-how-anti-vaxxers-conspiracy-theorists-and-the-far-right-came-together-over-covid-168383>.  

Roussos, Eleni. "Remote Aboriginal Communities Battle Misinformation in Race against Time to Boost Vaccination Rates." ABC News 28 Oct. 2021. 30 Oct. 2021 <https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-10-28/nt-remote-communities-covid-vaccination-santa-teresa-ali-curung/10057223029>.

Russonello, Giovanni. "Afraid of Coronavirus? That Might Say Something about Your Politics." The New York Times 13 Mar. 2020. 6 Sep. 2021 <https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/13/us/politics/coronavirus-trump-polling.html>.  

Smith, Andrea C., Jacqueline Woerner, Rochelle Perera, Angela M. Haeny, and Jonathan M. Cox. "An Investigation of Associations between Race, Ethnicity, and Past Experiences of Discrimination with Medical Mistrust and Covid-19 Protective Strategies." Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities (2021): 1-13. <https://doi.org/10.1007/s40615-021-01080-x>.

Stayner, Tom. "‘Misinformation’ Is Stalling Indigenous Vaccination Rates, National Cabinet Warns." SBS News 27 Jan. 2022.  29 Jan. 2022 <https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/misinformation-is-stalling-indigenous-vaccination-rates-national-cabinet-warns/s53sbbmo1>..

Stefanoff, Lisa. "Whatever It Takes: The Politics of Indigenous Vulnerability and Extracted Futures in Northern Australia." Arena Quarterly 3 Sep. 2020. 2 Aug. 2021 <https://arena.org.au/whatever-it-takes-the-politics-of-indigenous-vulnerability-and-extracted-futures-in-northern-australia/>.

Stevens, Wesley E. "Blackfishing on Instagram: Influencing and the Commodification of Black Urban Aesthetics." Social Media + Society 7.3 (2021).

Syron, Mikele. "Victoria Sees First Nations Vaccine Success with Pfizer Rollout." NITV 16 July 2021. 5 Aug. 2021 <https://www.sbs.com.au/nitv/article/2021/07/13/victoria-sees-first-nations-vaccine-success-pfizer-rollout>.

Thomas, Zoe. "Coronavirus: How Facebook, Tiktok and Other Apps Tackle Fake Claims." BBC News 1 Feb. 2020. 15 Aug. 2021 <https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51337357>.

Trudgen, Richard, Djiniyini Gondarra, and Kerry Mills. Proposal Covid-19 Community Education Program. Why Warriors, 2021. <https://www.whywarriors.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/COMMUNITY-EDUCATION-TO-TACKLE-VACCINE-HESITANCY-IN-REMOTE-ABORIGINAL-COMMUNITIES-191021.pdf>.

Turner, Bryan S. "Theodicies of the Covid-19 Catastrophe." Covid-19. Ed. J. Michael Ryan. London: Routledge, 2020. 29-42.

uprisingofthepeople. "My Mob Said It Was Okay." TikTok Sep 2021. 1 Oct. 2021. <https://www.tiktok.com/@uprisingofthepeople/video/7010266225758571777>.

Vosoughi, Soroush, Deb Roy, and Sinan Aral. "The Spread of True and False News Online." Science 359.6380 (2018): 1146-51. <https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aap9559>.

Waight, Nerita. “Urgent Action on Prisons to Avoid COVD-19 Deaths.” IndigenousX 20 Aug. 2020. 2 Sep. 2021 <https://indigenousx.com.au/urgent-action-on-prisons-to-avoid-covid-19-deaths/>.

Weismueller, Jason, Jacob Shapiro, Jan Oldedan, and Paul Harrigan. "Coronavirus Misinformation Is a Global Issue, But Which Myth You Fall for Likely Depends on Where You Live." The Conversation 12 Aug. 2020. 3 Sep. 2021 <https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-misinformation-is-a-global-issue-but-which-myth-you-fall-for-likely-depends-on-where-you-live-143352>.

Why Warriors. "Why Warrirors." 19 Nov. 2021 <https://www.whywarriors.com.au/>.

Wilson‐Matenga, Geraldine, Megan Campbell, Rachel Katterl, Elizabeth Ellis, and Robert Skeen. "Partnership, Trust and Respect: NSW's Response to Covid‐19 among Aboriginal People." Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 45.4 (2021): 315. <https://dx.doi.org/10.1111%2F1753-6405.13138>.

World Health Organization. An Overview of Infodemic Management during Covid-19, January 2020–May 2021. 2021.  <https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240035966>.

Wyatt, Ken. "Aboriginal Christian Leadership Unite on Covid Messaging." Media Release. 6 Sep. 2021. <https://nacchocommunique.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Media-Release-Min-Wyatt-mtg-with-religious-leaders-re-vax-misinfo-6.9.21.pdf>.

Author Biographies

Bronwyn Fredericks, Professor and Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Indigenous Engagement), University of Queensland

Bronwyn Fredericks PhD is a Professor and the Pro-Vice-Chancellor (Indigenous Engagement) at the University of Queensland. She has over 30 years’ experience working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, Indigenous health organisations, NGOs and Government agencies. Her research, based in the fields of health and education and grounded within the political reality of Indigenous peoples’ daily lives, exemplifies her commitment to social justice and improving Indigenous health and education outcomes. 

Abraham Bradfield, Research Officer, Office of the Pro-Vice Chancellor (Indigenous Engagement), University of Queensland

Dr Abraham Bradfield is a Research Officer with the Office of the Pro-Vice Chancellor (Indigenous Engagement) at The University of Queensland. Completing his PhD in 2018 in Anthropology and Social Sciences (UNSW) his research explores topics relating to colonisation, decolonisation, identity, and the intercultural. He remains committed to developing and implementing morally responsible research that challenges colonial power structures and encourages new habits of thought and praxis

Sue McAvoy, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for the Business and Economics of Health (CBEH) and Business School (UQBS), University of Queensland

Dr Sue McAvoy (Vollert) is a Senior Research Fellow with the University of Queensland’s Centre for the Business and Economics of Health (CBEH) and Business School (UQBS). Sue researches, teaches, and consults extensively in the discipline of System Dynamics. She has 30-years’ experience as a senior leader in Treasury operations and foreign exchange risk management in both the public and private sector. Over the past ten years, Sue has developed a strong competency in Systems Thinking and System Dynamics modelling.

James Ward, Director of the Poche Centre for Indigenous Health, University of Queensland

Professor James Ward is a Pitjantjatjara and Nukunu man, an infectious diseases epidemiologist and a national leader in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander research. He is currently the Director of the Poche Centre for Indigenous Health at The University of Queensland. James has over 25 years in Aboriginal public health policy for both government and non-government organisations, in urban, regional, and remote communities. He has built a national program of research in the epidemiology and prevention of infectious diseases in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities.

Shea Spierings, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, POCHE Centre for Indigenous Health, University of Queensland

Shea Spierings is a Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Queensland’s POCHE Centre for Indigenous Health. His current research is focused on COVID-19 health messaging in Indigenous communities, and Aboriginal men’s health. Shea’s PhD research investigated Aboriginal men’s stories to highlight the complex intersection between the criminalisation of Indigeneity, Aboriginal masculinity, and Aboriginal health. Shea previously worked in the Indigenous Community Controlled Health Sector.

Troy Combo, Senior Research Assistant, POCHE Centre for Indigenous Health, University of Queensland

Troy Combo is a Senior Research Assistant with University of Queensland’s POCHE Centre for Indigenous Health. He also holds an affiliation with the Burnet Institute where he is the national Program Manager for the Eliminate Hepatitis C Australia Partnership. He is a current Master of Philosophy Candidate at the UQ School of Public Health and is undertaking an ecological study of Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander drug user networks.

Agnes Toth-Peter, Research Assistant, University of Queensland

Agnes Toth-Peter is a research assistant at the University of Queensland with a background in systems thinking and system dynamics. Agnes is currently undertaking her PhD in circular economy at the Queensland University of Technology